I was eager to read Bob Chapek’s memoir, Behind the Castle Walls, immediately when it came out, expecting a petty and vindictive recounting of his tenure as CEO and his abrupt ouster. Judging by the sales numbers, apparently I was among a dedicated few who were so excited.
In case you don’t follow Disney corporate drama (I envy you): Chapek spent nearly thirty years at Disney, ran its theme parks from 2015 to 2020, and was picked by Bob Iger to succeed him as CEO in February 2020, weeks before COVID closed the domestic parks. In November 2022 the board fired him, and Iger returned as CEO. This book is his side of it. I listened to the audiobook, which he reads himself.

This was always going to be a cathartic hate-read: I was among the DisTwitter faithful who, in the wake of that November announcement, felt hopeful about the future of the Parks product after years of watching Chapek seemingly misunderstand its core appeal and service to American culture. But, despite the dominant viewpoint of my peers, I was ready to hear Chapek out: maybe this book would give me a better understanding of his perspective, and maybe even make me feel a little more sympathetic to him. And you know what? It did, at least a little — for reasons I didn’t see coming and in ways that inform how I think about my career in Product. At the same time, though, Bob’s own words continually confirmed my priors that he was a poor steward of the Disney brand.
If you only paid attention to the top-line news since 2020, you might be thinking: Didn’t Chapek shepherd Disney through the uncertain, turbulent COVID era, and oversee significant growth in many of its business units? You’re going to argue someone who successfully led the company through that is a poor steward? I’ll admit: Chapek is an excellent operator. He knows how to drive the metrics that are asked of him. It’s not surprising that he rose to the station that he did. But, even though it’s cheesy and cliche to point out, first-order metrics aren’t the only component in measuring success. Being able to extract revenue gains from a business’s assets doesn’t mean it’s free money, or that it doesn’t come with a cost somewhere else. At Disney, that cost comes out of the genesis of its value: the trust and love families have for it, a key part of the “flywheel” Chapek loves to champion, and the one he seems to continually take for granted.
Before the parks: The Disruptor#
I’ve always considered myself a disruptor.
— Chapter Four, “Entering the Magic Kingdom”
Chapek didn’t come up through the parks. In fact, unlike all the men who preceded him as the head of Disney’s Parks divisionBob's PredecessorsBob's Predecessors#The Parks org has gone by many names over the years:
In 1980, OG Disneyland cast trainer Dick Nunis became president of Walt Disney Productions’ “Outdoor Recreation” division.
By the time he retired in 1999, it was “Walt Disney Attractions,” and he was succeeded by Judson Green, a Walt Disney World and Euro Disneyland finance veteran who’d been running the parks day-to-day since 1991. Four-year Disneyland president Paul Pressler took the reins in 2000.
In 2002, Euro Disney veteran Jay Rasulo rose to lead the expanded “Walt Disney Parks & Resorts.”
2010 saw the appointment of Chapek’s immediate predecessor, Tom Staggs, who had represented Disney on Euro Disney’s supervisory board., he had no theme park experience at all prior to his Chairmanship. He spent his first two decades at Disney selling its movies for Home Video, then running the studio’s distribution and its consumer products business: the Disney Store, toys, books, etc. The first third of the book covers those years, and you’re meant to come away from it thinking: “This guy really fancies himself a disruptor; it’s like his entire identity!”
Here’s the lightning round of the disruptive feathers in his cap as he sees them:
| The bet | The story | His lesson |
|---|---|---|
| Low-fat cat food | As an assistant product manager on 9Lives cat food at Heinz, Bob noticed a nationwide diet craze and a lot of overweight cats (Genie finds this rude). Product development said a new diet food would take 18 months, so he slapped “95 percent fat free” labels on the existing leaner flavors and declared success. He calls it “foundational to [his] management philosophy for the rest of [his] career.” | Why craft something new when you can extract more value from the assets you already have? |
| The Disney Vault | At Disney’s home video division in the early ’90s, research showed people weren’t buying classics like Bambi on VHS because they “simply hadn’t gotten around to it.” So his team pulled beloved films off the market for years at a time, building “a sense of scarcity, which increased demand.” | Make what people love harder to get, and they’ll pay more for it and act quickly to get it. |
| Direct-to-video sequels | Aladdin was a smash, and consumers said they wanted more. Feature Animation refused to make “derivative slop” (we love a pre-AI use of the word), so Bob cajoled TV Animation into making The Return of Jafar for under $10 million. He was happy with the quality “given the modest budget … plus the fact that the primary audience would be young kids.” Nearly $300 million in sales probably didn’t hurt, either. | If customers keep buying it, product quality must be good enough! |
| Blu-ray | During the mid-2000s high-def format war, most of the industry backed HD DVD to protect existing patent royalties. Bob threw Disney’s weight behind Sony’s Blu-ray, the technically superior format, took heat from the industry, and turned down a $100 million incentive to switch. | Back the better product, even when the legacy industry won’t. |
| Shorter theatrical windows | Bob Iger wanted movies on DVD sooner after their theatrical run, while interest was still high. Chapek took the heat and ran the test with 2010’s Alice in Wonderland, despite theaters threatening a boycott and an angry Tim Burton. The theaters relented, Alice made over $1 billion worldwide, and the early DVD “didn’t impact the movie’s theater sales at all.” | Sometimes disruption will mean burning bridges. |
| The Disney Store | Now running all of consumer products, Bob found cheap merchandise being marked down even further when it didn’t sell. He banned discounts, because “part of that magic involved offering products worth buying—items genuinely worth their price.” After raising prices, the stores made $300 million a year. | Price is how customers know something is worth it, and they’ll pay more for a higher-quality product. |
When I review Chapek’s disruption highlight reel, I see two Bobs — no, not Chapek and Iger, but two beings inside Chapek himself. Blu-ray Bob/ Disney Store Bob/Shorter Theatrical Window BobIger's ideaIger's idea#I hesitate to give Chapek too much credit for the window test: this truly was Iger’s product idea Chapek was just carrying out. Again, he’s a great operator.
What I do want to give him credit for is being introspective for one of the only times in this whole book: he admits that the window test “became the source of some ongoing tension between me and the creative community” has a genuine eye for a better product or experience for the end user, even over objections of a legacy industry. Vault Bob/Cat Food Bob/Sequel Bob seeks to grow the business by extracting more out of the assets he already has by leveraging latent demand in the market — it’s easier than making something new, and he can wave off criticism by claiming he’s giving the customer something they clearly want. Parents want to own Bambi for their toddler’s repeated viewings. 87% of survey respondents said they wanted more from the stories they loved, so: more Aladdin.
What both Bobs Chapek have in common is their scorecard: both judge the outcomes of their accomplishments in point-in-time surveys, annual sales figures, and price tags. On that scorecard, Blu-ray and the Vault aren’t differentiated: both made a lot of money! But consider: Blu-ray gave consumers a clearly better experience, and a shorter theatrical window gave them the opportunity to watch the movie at home earlier. Both increased the Disney brand’s credit with consumers. Repeated artificial scarcity from the Vault and a string of low-quality sequels spends that credit. When your scorecard can’t differentiate that (unless you’re measuring surveys over a period of years, or even decades), it makes it easier to ignore the fact that the customer love and trust underpinning the assets’ value is not infinite, and each instance of extracting more from them is a withdrawal against that love and trust. Families bought The Return of Jafar because they loved Aladdin — proof that Aladdin still had credit with them, not that Jafar added any.
And Bob’s not an idiot: he knows how this works. On a podcast promoting this book, when asked what Disney would never compromise, Chapek cites Steve Jobs’s “brand deposits and brand withdrawals” concept. He explicitly calls out that you “have to put in a lot more than you can ever take out.” And to his credit, he does show restraint in some cases: he refused to open the Vault early even when his bosses begged for the revenue to hit in the current reporting period. He turned down $100 million in incentives to back Blu-ray. However, his reasons for this restraint show the imperfection in the application: The Vault stays shut because opening it would destroy “the entire system that was printing money for the company.” Blu-ray is chosen because it’s the better product, sure, but of course Bob sees its financial potential: it could “generate way more than $100 million every year for the next decade.” The restraint isn’t in the service of safeguarding the brand’s credit with consumers: it’s to extend the life of the asset’s value to the business. So despite his quoting of Jobs, with a few exceptions, I’d be hard-pressed to characterize the lion’s share of his “disruptions” as making a brand “deposit.”
For a marketer working in packaged goods, maybe ignoring the brand bank as someone else’s job is excusable. No one has an emotional attachment to cat food, for example. But Disney’s product, and entertainment as a whole for that matter, is something a bit more complex. Chapek even remarks, “I knew Disney hadn’t hired me to be a part of the entertainment world; they’d hired me to sell the next product, which happened to be intellectual property.” But we know his ambitions were always larger than being “the marketing guy.” On his first date with his future wife, he tells her, “I’m going to be a CEO one day.” He later makes clear that he intends for this to happen at Disney: “if I left Disney without becoming the CEO, I would consider my time there a failure.”Can you change verticals?Can you change verticals?#After spending six years in big tech, I recently went through a job search that included startups/non-devtools companies. I found myself expressing disgust at “hiring takes” alleging that candidates who spend too long at big companies are unsuited to work at startups, or pigeonholing candidates with years of experience in an industry. I always assumed: surely a good candidate can apply their craft to a different industry, even if the product and customers are very different? Watching Chapek ply his packaged-goods playbook at a company that sells experiences is the first time I’ve truly understood what these folks are talking about. For this reason, I think it’s perfectly fair to criticize him for displaying little care for the craft behind a product that means so much to its audience.
In fact, he occasionally displays active contempt for the creative side of the business. When critics called The Return of Jafar “cheap” (and cmon, can you blame them?) Chapek decided they were threatened: “Likely because a bunch of upstart TV animators in their twenties had created something that generated five times the profits of a typical theatrical release” (I truly doubt these professional artisans were jealous of the profits). When executives doubted his sequels, he offered to show his market research, “but they never wanted to see it, probably because they knew it would contradict their assumptions” (or perhaps they understood the danger of over-drafting the brand account, or the stated preference/revealed preference gap).Welcome to HollywoodWelcome to Hollywood#Chapek remarks from his first weeks in Burbank that “Often in Hollywood, decisions are driven not by the truth and what’s best for business but rather by legacy and vested interests.” While I’m right there with him that Hollywood’s prestige and legacy make disruption more difficult, the fact that he combines “truth” and “what’s best for business” is telling that he’s missing a key part of the equation: the product! He’s assuming that it would contradict their assumptions rather than interrogating whether there’s an opportunity for him to learn another viewpoint here. I would assume that someone who wants to be CEO would want to understand every stakeholder’s view so they can grow to be a good steward of the whole company (to be frank, I’d assume someone who just wants to be the best marketing guy would want to get a handle on all that too, but I digress). But Bob seems to think he has it all figured out, and that the financial results alone are enough proof: “Even seasoned entertainment execs who still resent the idea of sequels now realize how much money there is in just giving the customer what they want.”
Reading through the twenty years before Chapek entered my theme-park-following bubble has given me a new lens through which to view the tenure I followed closely from 2015-2022. The two Bobs show up again during his time leading Parks — Blu-ray Bob bets on Disneyland Paris and Star Wars: Galactic Starcruiser, Vault Bob keeps finding ways to coax a few more dollars out of each guest. And the scorecard follows him all the way to the CEO’s shower-adorned office#Well, not quite the one with the shower. This will make sense in Part II, I promise., where the parts of the job it can’t measure turn out to be the parts that matter most. I also continue to get the sneaking suspicion through some Inglorious Basterds-esque tells that Chapek truly doesn’t have the deep care of the product that his predecessors had.
That’s all to come in Part II, should I get around to polishing my notes enough to publish them! I have a lot to say!!



Comments
Comments load as you scroll here.